1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Would You Kill A Seal ?

Discussion in 'Sea Fishing Forum - Shore, Boat & Kayak Fishing' started by Baramundi Bob, Mar 3, 2009.


If your livlihood was threatened would you kill a seal ??

  1. Yes I would kill a seal

    34 vote(s)
  2. No I could never do that

    16 vote(s)
  1. mattylamb

    mattylamb Rockling

    southerners first I reckon Simon :laugh:
  2. riley.

    riley. Blenny

    like other specific animals/vermin that are posioned to maintain a healthy level...they are still not wanted around farms and businesses and same would go for seals....all though seals are less of a problem compared to something else i think ways can be done to sort some soulotion out......
  3. Maxie

    Maxie New Member

    when i was a kid 10 :embarrass: no maybe 30 years back i never seen a seal local to me but i often see them now.
    its the same as a lot of things,i never seen a buzzard till about ten years back now they are ten a penny,kestrels,even peregrines they are pretty common.
    and as for magpies and jackdaws :evil: some of them might die on my allotment this year theres a plague of them.
    most of these are the top of their food chains so have no predators to keep their numbers down.

    THE OUTCAST Whitby Fishing Forum _ Simply The Best

    I would kill some of the netters and longliners
    If man had not and did not rape the sea in the first place there would be no probs.
    its time we used by catchers and stopped blaming seals =birds =others out there its
    Mans fault there is feck all out there we take take take and give nowt back into the food stocks .
    rant over ish,,
  5. rubbish

    rubbish New Member

    no for me, livelyhood or not. they are only evolving around mans destruction.
  6. shammy67

    shammy67 only dead fish go with the flow

    well said outcast..couldnt agree more.as i said in an earlier post on this subject,the seals are just being used as scapegoats...in my opinion
  7. riley.

    riley. Blenny

    think of the seals as illegal immigrants too many and there's a problem
  8. Dav

    Dav Rockling

    There`s me thinking the problem of lack of fish around our coast was down to them big vessels we call trawlers :whistle:
  9. Dorado

    Dorado New Member

    They're not being used as scapegoats, just coats...well and boots.
  10. IanB

    IanB Blenny

    There are definately too many do-gooders on this planet, you're only here for a short time
    so make the most of it. I personally would shoot one - no bother.
    There are far too many seals around our coast now, even years ago (30-40) if a seal turned
    up whilst you were fishing that was it for hours, no wonder there is no fish hardly on the beaches
    with the amount of seals about.
    I know that they were shot from boats around here 30 year ago and there was'nt many then.
  11. Chris j

    Chris j Whitby Fishing Forum _ Simply The Best

    I'm a brikkie if the seals start threatening my livelihood lets kill em.its bad enough with the poles
  12. Supersonic

    Supersonic Whitby Bass Club

    Seriously I was at the river Hull in BEVERLEY the other day and a seal took a kid's livebaited trout meant for pike. He had the beast on for 20 minutes :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

    On the question, yes I would if it was affecting my livelihood. I hate this attitude that people seem to have about if the animal's bigger it's less acceptable to kill it. Think of killing a spider. No problem. A rabbit?? A Seal??
  13. Baramundi Bob

    Baramundi Bob Super Leeds United !!!

    Have you watched the comedian Dennis Leary. He does an excellent sketch on how humans are happy to killer ugly looking creatures and protect the cutest ones. He swears a fair bit but makes an excellent point.

    Talking of catching seals. I once did battle with a seal and won whilst uptiding with Killer. Halfway in the seal took my fish. I clicked the reel out of gear and watched the seal strip the line. Then I clicked the real in gear and the seal let go. I wound half way in and the seal took it again. I did the same again and it let go again. This time I got the fish on the boat. Bar a few scratches it was unmarked. Not sure how a seal would hold a fish ??

    THE OUTCAST Whitby Fishing Forum _ Simply The Best

    A MAN now that is easy and a big target.
    now that makes any one setting a net or long line fair game as he is taking your fish..
  15. smokey

    smokey Rockling

    Put your hand near a seals mouth and see how friendly it is then.All the do gooders in this world should be shot,then fed to the seals,maybe the fish population would rise then..tight lines
  16. Dink

    Dink Blenny

    Well said Smokey!! :yes:
  17. riley.

    riley. Blenny

    couldnt agree more smokey lad.......i see them seals!.....they look at you!! especially the big fat ones....are they curious or are they eyeing you up for dinner...... i make seal noises!!!! i'm bonkers...
  18. go go gadget

    go go gadget New Member

    :laugh: :laugh:
  19. foo

    foo You've gotta be in it to win it.

    Foxes of the sea and often kill fish wantonly just for the sake of it and seem to enjoy it taking a single bite and discarding the rest.Would kill a seal without a second thought.
  20. shammy67

    shammy67 only dead fish go with the flow

    U opened a rite can of worms ere glenn!!..i aint a do-gooder,but it was only last week that glenn posted a story of a trawler landing 1,900 tonnes (at least) of mackeral...if the mackeral dont show this year,do we have the right to blow up that trawler?...take your blinkers off n look at the real picture...that trawler is the tip of the iceberg..no seal colony,however big,can cause as much destruction to the fish stocks as we do..http://www.whitbyseaanglers.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=12.0

Share This Page